Hiring Mistakes, We See Often and How to Fix Them
Hiring Mistakes, We See Often and How to Fix Them
For Employers in Construction, Engineering, Architecture & Property
In a market where talent is tight, hiring well matters more than ever. Yet even the most experienced businesses — from Tier 1 contractors to boutique consultancies are making hiring mistakes that cost time, money, and momentum.
At Oceania Careers, we’ve seen it all: drawn-out processes, unclear briefs, culture mismatches, and offers that come too late. The good news? Most hiring mistakes are fixable and many are avoidable with a few simple shifts.
Here are the most common hiring mistakes we see and how your business can fix (or prevent) them.
1. Waiting Too Long to Start the Process
Too many businesses wait until someone resigns or a project kicks off before thinking about hiring. That puts you in a reactive position, trying to fill roles under pressure.
The fix:
- Build a proactive workforce plan aligned to your pipeline
- Always be on the lookout for talent, even when you’re not actively hiring
- Engage a recruitment partner early to map the market
When you plan ahead, you buy time and choice.
2. Vague or Generic Job Briefs
If you don’t know what you’re looking for, neither will candidates. Generic PDs with laundry lists of tasks confuse top talent and attract the wrong applicants.
The fix:
- Write clear, outcome-based briefs: what will success look like in 6–12 months?
- Prioritise must-haves vs. nice-to-haves
- Speak to your recruiter or internal team about what the market is actually delivering
Remember: specificity attracts the right people.
3. Overly Long Hiring Processes
We’ve seen firms lose brilliant candidates because they took too long to decide or added unnecessary interview rounds.
The fix:
- Streamline your process (ideally no more than 2–3 stages)
- Be clear with candidates about timelines from the start
- Prioritise responsiveness — momentum signals professionalism
Top talent moves fast. So should you.
4. Prioritising Perfect CVs Over Potential
Great candidates don’t always tick every box on paper — but they can often grow into the role and deliver exceptional outcomes.
The fix:
- Focus on capability, attitude and adaptability
- Use interviews to explore fit, not just experience
- Ask yourself: “Can they learn this quickly?” rather than “Have they done this exact thing?”
Some of your best hires won’t come from obvious backgrounds.
5. Under-Communicating During the Process
Silence or vague updates during a hiring process erode trust. Candidates disengage, get anxious, or accept other offers.
The fix:
- Set clear expectations around timing and communication
- Provide honest updates — even if it’s a “we’re still deciding”
- Treat every candidate like a potential ambassador for your brand
People remember how they were treated — whether they get the job or not.
6. Rushing the Offer (or Getting It Wrong)
We’ve seen candidates walk away from offers that were rushed, unclear, or didn’t reflect the earlier conversation.
The fix:
- Discuss salary expectations early
- Make offers that reflect market value, role responsibility, and progression
- Deliver the offer with confidence and be ready to answer questions
An offer is a key moment. Handle it well.
7. Forgetting About Onboarding
Hiring is just the beginning. Without structured onboarding, even great hires can flounder or leave early.
The fix:
- Plan the first 30–90 days: tools, introductions, expectations
- Set up regular check-ins with their manager and team
- Give early wins to build momentum and confidence
Done well, onboarding can be the difference between a good hire and a long-term team member.
Final Thought
Great hiring doesn’t happen by accident — it happens by design. The most successful firms in 2025 are the ones who approach hiring with clarity, pace, and purpose.
If you’re serious about attracting and keeping top talent, avoid these common mistakes and build a recruitment process that reflects the standard of your work.
Want to Hire Smarter?
- Follow Oceania Careers on LinkedIn for weekly hiring insights
- Get in touch for a confidential talent conversation. Whether you’re hiring now or planning ahead
- Subscribe to our newsletter for industry trends and our upcoming 2025 Salary Guide
